author
|
author
|
OnMilwaukee
OnMilwaukee is an independently-owned digital media company that focuses on creativity, community, and connection. The publication has a strong digital and social presence. For me, the first thing I noticed was the branding of the publication. The logo looks friendly and approachable, and includes a symbol that is recognizable to Milwaukeeans. When I browse through the site, I don’t feel as if it is being targeted to a certain gender. The simple primary color palette makes it neutral and appealing to people of any gender. In regards to age, I feel that the demographic that is being targeted is 25-35-year-old, young professionals. The UX of the site is simple. There are only 3 tabs on the navigation bar (“Home”, “Guides”, and “on/anything”) and a large search bar up top. The website is a continuous scroll, but there are some featured articles on top, along with a featured authors section and latest podcast section. Article: 19 rooftop patios to explore before summer’s end This article is in list format. It gives a brief 3-5 sentence summary of 19 different rooftop patio restaurants in the Milwaukee area. It definitely appeals to OnMilwaukee’s target audience that I mentioned above. I personally find this article appealing because I am always looking for new restaurants to check out and I love well-designed spaces with a good view so the content of the article was of interest to me. I thought the photos were stunning and gave a good representation of each of the rooftops that were discussed. Shepherd Express Right off the bat, the look and feel of this site is different from OnMilwaukee. It feels geared towards an older audience. There are 17 tabs on the navigation bar. It is not a continuous scroll, but similarly to OnMilwaukee, it has the latest articles at the top of the page. Different sections- for example, music, sports, food- and their featured articles are organized in a cluster-like way. The Shepherd Express is a free weekly newspaper featuring independent local journalism. They have options to financially support the publication by becoming a member and getting perks. Article: This Week in Milwaukee: Aug. 26-Sept. 1, 2021 I think the article was well-organized. It had headers with dates, then subheadings with the title of the event, location and time, then below was the body which goes into more detail about the event. I liked that they went into detail explaining the Japanese Taiko drum performance and the significance that it has in Japanese culture. I liked that they inserted a youtube video of one of the performances from a past year. The typeface that’s used for the article feels a bit “old” and boring. Not something I personally find appealing but it makes sense for their audience. Another thing about this article is there weren’t many photos. I think one of the photos is placed under the wrong date/event. Urban Milwaukee The Urban Milwaukee publication was founded in 2008. It feels like it’s geared towards an older audience based on the design. There are 6 tabs up top, when you hover over the tabs, “sub-tabs” pop up. There is one big article at the top then as you scroll, it’s just a long list of articles not organized in any specific way. It seems to publish more “mature,” adult articles. Article: Family Files Complaint For Discrimination Against Native Students This article felt like a more formal news article. It included lots of quotes from the parties involved. There is one photo at the top, but none throughout the article. The point size of the text is smaller than the other publications I looked at. Milwaukee Magazine The UX of the website feels more interesting and modern than urbanmilwaukee and the Shepherd Express. The typefaces feel more “fresh.” There are 10 tabs at the top and a side navigation bar as well. It feels geared towards a younger audience, maybe 25-35 year olds. There’s a “slideshow” of articles at the top, trending articles, then as you scroll down, they’re organized by topic. Article: You Can Have Your Portrait Taken Today for an International Art Project There is one photo at the very top of the article. There is a main article title, a brief subhead right underneath and the author’s name. This is a very short article. It seems like the main goal is to spread information (date, location, time) and briefly explain the event. It has hyperlinks throughout the article. Milwaukee Record It feels like the audience for Milwaukee Record is 35-40 year old males. It has a navigation bar at the top and their socials listed right below. The featured articles are arranged like a gallery at the top. It seems to have a heavy focus on music and local events. They have certain features like “Record Recommended” and “Mandatory Milwaukee”. Article: Mandatory Milwaukee: Art and nature collide at Lynden Sculpture Garden This article has lots of photos of the sculpture garden. The article is written in an informal and conversational manner, but still provides relevant information. It gives history of the garden and has links embedded in the article. There are captions on some photos of sculptures stating the title of the piece and the artist’s name i-D i-D has been creating editorial content for over 30 years and started as a fashion fanzine. It is now a magazine and digital publication. It covers topics like news, culture, fashion, photography, music, beauty, and communities in the U.S. The target audience seems to be young people, maybe 18-25 years old. There is one giant photo/article when you open the site, which spans across the whole screen. Then as you scroll, there’s a “today in i-D” section and “features” section. There is a specific aesthetic of how the website is designed. Some of the headings are all lowercase, including the first letter of the word. Only sans serif typefaces are used. Article: The queer artist exploring masculinity with Medieval symbols The article features 6 pieces of artwork from Jakob Rowlinson and digs deep into the imagery and motifs that he uses. The article is well written, formal and scholarly. It contains some big vocabulary words that I didn’t know the meanings of. It was an interview but it didn’t feel like an interview- the quotes from the artist were scattered thoughtfully throughout the article. The images of the artwork were placed every two paragraphs, so it felt balanced. The images were crisp and high quality. I do wish there were little captions with titles of each piece.
11 Comments
Anna
9/16/2021 01:22:51 pm
I thought it was really interesting on how you focused on the OnMilwaukee logo. I am not a CD major, but I do understand how the look of the logo can affect the overall mood of a website/brand, without anyone actually reading the articles. I also really like how you took into consideration the UI/UX design of each of the websites, since most of the other blog posts seem to be focused more on the content.
Reply
Alexis
9/18/2021 04:20:21 pm
Hey Erin! I love the use of links, but maybe you could include them into the text with a hyperlink so they don't stick out as much! I like how you talk about the UX of some of the websites. I like to see your opinion on that since I know you are a CD major and definitely know more about that type of stuff than I do haha
Reply
Juliana
9/19/2021 03:03:53 pm
Hey Erin, I really appreciated how much information you included and how everything was really easy to find. I can tell you did a lot of research.
Reply
Taj
9/20/2021 09:46:28 am
Hey Erin, I really enjoy your landing page for starters. Your first post was very informative and I like that you put alot of thought into evaluating the UX design of the websites. That's a strong point that supports the need for accessibility for readers.
Reply
Care
9/20/2021 10:10:16 am
It's nice that you've included links to each of the sources and specific articles you've read so we're able to know exactly what you're referring to and look further into these ideas if we'd like. I think the national site you chose, i-D, is really interesting. As a queer person, I enjoy how much queer news it features on the homepage. The article you chose from i-D is also quite refreshing, about queer art. Unless we specifically search for them, it's pretty rare from what I've seen for queer news, especially queer art to be represented in articles, especially featured.
Reply
Julia
9/20/2021 01:13:57 pm
I really enjoyed reading your analysis on each different news site. Your brief descriptions of each article you read are clear and concise. I enjoyed your comments sharing your own thoughts about the sites as well.
Reply
Olivia Lorber
9/20/2021 01:32:21 pm
Hi Erin! The structure of your reviews is very well organized and easy to read. I love how you split up the overall review of the site and your thoughts on the specific article you read. You did very well as describing an article with a lot of information in just a few sentences. You have a very clear and engaging way of writing :)
Reply
Rachel
9/20/2021 01:50:50 pm
Nice post, it was easy to follow and the paragraphs split it up into easily-read pieces. Your information was awesome and was a good amount; not too little or too overwhelming.
Reply
Ryan
9/20/2021 02:15:02 pm
I think you did a really well job emulating the sources we were looking at. Straight to the point but you give us enough info to get the general idea of what were looking at. I enjoyed your own personal voice integrated throughout.
Reply
9/20/2021 03:12:29 pm
Nice portfolio and landing page artwork. Good commentary on the formatting of the various online publications. Nice review of content written into the reviewed articles.
Reply
Taylor
9/22/2021 03:36:45 pm
I really like your balance of comments from aesthetics to content. Good information provided on the sites!
Reply
Leave a Reply. |
|
CW.org |
|